A sermon for the final service at Trinity Episcopal Church of Morrisania, Bronx, NY
Fourth Sunday of Advent/Christmas Eve, December 24, 2023
He has mercy on those who fear him in every generation.
He has shown the strength of his arm, he has scattered the proud in their conceit.
He has cast down the mighty from their thrones, and has lifted up the lowly.
He has filled the hungry with good things, and the rich he has sent away empty.
In today’s Gospel the angel announces to Mary what God is about to do. And, according to ancient theology, this is the very moment of the Incarnation, the moment when the Almighty, the Infinite and Unknowable Source of All enters into the womb a woman and becomes flesh—one of us. The Orthodox churches call Mary “Theotokos,” which means God bearer. And God bearer IS truly the most awe-inspiring thought possible: a woman carrying the wholeness of God within herself. And what our story today makes crystal clear is that Mary, Theotokos, God-bearer, is not someone of rank, of wealth, of importance.
After the angel’s visitation, Mary went to the hills to visit her older cousin Elizabeth and that’s when she sang the song that I quoted at the beginning of this sermon. She praises God for God’s greatness and favor—favor not to the proud, or the powerful, or the wealthy, but to the lowly, the hungry, and the poor—those to whom God has particularly granted mercy. She was bearing a child within her, and that person was to deliver God’s mercy into this world—to be our savior.
How do we know that Mary didn’t talk about experiencing God’s mercy to the lowly, the hungry, and the poor merely as an intellectual exercise? Well, we know it because, when this woman, this God-bearer, this Theotokos, was getting near to her due date, she was forced, because of the Emperor’s decree, to walk many miles to Bethlehem. There’s no evidence in Scripture that she even had a donkey to ride on like you often see in paintings. No, she walked those many miles while pregnant and when she arrived, there was no hospital, no hotel, not even a bed in a small inn. Mary, the God-bearer, Theotokos, gave birth in a stable and Jesus—God come among us—was laid in a manger.
There’s another voyage I want to talk about today because in the Christian church it is the custom to observe the feast of a saint on the day of their death. Saint Wendell Roberts died on December 24, 2005, fifty-five years after he first came to Trinity Episcopal Church of Morrisania. Father Roberts, who was originally from Jamaica, was called to a church in a neighborhood that was very much in transition, with many new immigrants arriving, especially from the West Indies. Previously a number of old members had encouraged Fr. Theopold to move the church to a more prosperous area, but Fr. Theopold saw many Anglicans among those immigrants and encouraged the church to stay. When Fr. Roberts arrived, he discovered that New York City’s plan to build the Forest Houses included taking over Trinity’s property. Father Roberts and his congregation were having none of it – he could see all the ministry that would be needed and wanted among the old and new residents. He contacted the bishop and the Diocese of New York and Trinity stood up to Robert Moses and the city housing authority and the church remained.
The church remained. In 1950 Bishop Gilbert appointed Father Roberts as the first Black priest to be Priest-in-Charge at Trinity. Father Roberts tirelessly worked to build up the congregation, visiting parishioners, welcoming new members, organizing and making sure that others organized activities. By 1956 Trinity was sponsor of the Bronx Church League basketball champions. There was a picture in the parish hall of Father Roberts, Mr. Richardson the coach, and that team—it looked like it could have done well against Fordham. The church prospered with a full Sunday school, a boy choir, ranks of disciplined acolytes, and guilds.
Wendell Roberts tirelessly ministered: baptizing, teaching, marrying, and burying; standing courageously with the people of Trinity and the Morrisania neighborhood through both good times and some of the worst times the Bronx ever faced. Wendell Roberts had heard the news of the God who has mercy on all who fear Him in every generation, who has lifted up the lowly and filled the hungry with good things. There’s a stained-glass window up by the altar in Wendell’s memory—but it doesn’t focus on Wendell—it shows Jesus the Good Shepherd tending his flock—Wendell was such a shepherd, his service was not about him but about that flock, those people who have worshiped here, and about our One True, Good Shepherd.
Today is Christmas Eve, the feast of the birth of Jesus, of what theologians call the Incarnation—God bursting into this world of everyday experience, the mercy and love of God worked out in real life. In real life the love of God encounters daily the pridefulness and conceit of human beings, the arrogance of the powerful and the self-interested manipulations of the rich. The witness of Jesus in this world is the mercy of God and in the real world it takes shape in those people he sends out into the world.
Our Epistle today is the very end of Paul’s letter to the Romans. It is the ending of a chapter where Paul concludes his last, and theologically most important letter, by sending greetings and commendations for people he names, noting their preciousness in the life of the church and for Paul’s own life:
“I commend to you our sister Phoebe, a deacon of the church…help her in whatever she may require from you, for she’s been a protector of many and of myself as well. Greet Prisca and Aquila who work with me in Christ Jesus and who risked their necks for my life…”
Romans 16:1-3
And he goes on naming fifteen others, both prominent workers in the church and those Paul mentions simply because of their care and love for others. Paul’s words remind me of the people of this congregation, those who are here and those who have been among us. I commend you all as witnesses of God’s mercy. Especially I commend those who we presented for confirmation just over a year ago: Bryce, Sureya, Omar, Joshua, Samora, Monica, and Mia. For those who have blessed us by their presence, but who have passed on, especially Arthur Lake, a teacher of many here, who was able to be present for his grandson’s confirmation before his final illness. Eileen Emmanuel, our faithful church secretary, or Barry Jones, who I remember tending the gardens outside. But I particularly commend those of you—faithful witnesses of Christ’s mercy—who now go forth into the world and the church to be the incarnation of Christ’s love: Wendell’s daughter Paula, who is our own Phoebe, serving and protecting this church and the people of this neighborhood; Crystal who has taken on so much, to serve the people who she loves and the God who cares for her. And those who have served here so long in so many ways—Lilas, Florence, Ona, Jeanie, Agnes, Judith, Luke, Linda, Gabriel, Eleanor, Marvin, Joe and Chang, Enid, Carol, and Locksley and Albert, my brothers on the altar every Sunday and so many others.
This church is closing … for now. Perhaps forever, as an Episcopal church, though, at this point, only God knows what is in store for our beloved church. We are sad, we are grieving. So many memories are here—baptisms, marriages, funerals—the full cycle of our time on earth. I want to tell you though, being among you as your pastor for these last years, has increased my faith and my hope for the church and for the world. God raised Jesus from the dead, and that life lives right here among you. The caring and goodness of the people here—how you know what Jesus wants and do it—that’s what the meaning of the one holy, and apostolic church is. And I see it in the people of this church, Trinity Episcopal Church of Morrisania.
I commend you—not only for your service here but for your ministry going forth, your love of all of God’s people wherever they are—wherever God’s mercy is needed. You are and remain the body of Christ.
Now to God who is able to strengthen you according to my gospel and the proclamation of Jesus Christ, according to the revelation of the mystery that was kept secret for long ages but is now disclosed, and through the prophetic writings is made known to all the Gentiles, according to the command of the eternal God, to bring about the obedience of faith— to the only wise God, through Jesus Christ, to whom be the glory forever! Amen.
Romans 16:25-27
And the blessing of God Almighty, the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit be with you always.
Merry Christmas, Everyone!